The gaming community recently witnessed the unveiling of the remastered version of Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, an acclaimed puzzle platformer, revamped for the year 2024 using advanced Unreal Engine 5 technology. Known for its rigorous technical analysis of gaming performance, Digital Foundry has put the game's new iteration through its paces and shared some illuminating results, especially regarding its performance on the latest Xbox consoles.
"The Series X shines with Unreal Engine 5," could be an apt summary of what the analysis found when it came to the top-tier Xbox model. The Xbox Series X managed to navigate the remade world of Brothers impressively well, generally rendering the game at a consistent and clear resolution, with 1440p being a common output, though the internal resolution could fluctuate anywhere from 1260p to 1620p. A 4K resolution may not have been witnessed during testing, but the Series X still had a lot to offer, especially when compared to its sibling, the Xbox Series S.
Performance modes on the Series X fluctuated but mostly in a positive manner. Even cut-scenes, which are locked at 30fps in the 60fps performance mode, and gameplay frame rates that waver from 35 to 60fps, appeared more stable on the Series X than on its counterpart, the PS5. The Series X often had a 10-15 percent frame rate advantage during game segments that required heavy lifting in terms of graphics, contributing to what can be described as a more "perceptually smooth result" for Variable Refresh Rate (VRR) displays.
As for the Xbox Series S, the analysis had some tough points to digest. The console definitely struggled, especially when it came to maintaining higher resolutions. In its 30fps mode, the Series S resolution ranged from a meager 454p to 720p, usually settling on the latter. The consequences of such low resolution were easily noticeable, even to an untrained eye. Visual disturbances, artifacts, and flickering were more apparent, and overall, the image was much softer and less defined—features that certainly did not translate well on 4K displays, which have become the standard for many gamers.
In performance mode, the Series S kept the resolution range between 454p and 720p, but more often than not, it hovered on the lower end of this spectrum, exacerbating the issues encountered in the quality mode. The picture's softness, coupled with the additional visual noise and artifacts, made for a less than optimal visual experience, particularly when compared to the Series X's performance.
For those eager to see the comparison in real time, Digital Foundry published a comprehensive video showcasing the differences across all game performance modes. The analysis conveyed that while the Series X version might not achieve 4K resolution, the gameplay experience was sufficiently robust, boasting higher frame rates and a smoother visual presentation. On the other hand, the figures for the Series S seemed unbecoming for a title released in 2024, a point that might disappoint gamers who own that console.
The resurgence of Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons serves as a reminder of the game's emotional depth and the unique gameplay dynamics between the two brothers, which have been praised widely by gamers and industry figures alike. Phil Spencer of Xbox has even recommended it for its distinct and touching narrative. Despite the technical shortcomings found in the Series S version of the remake, the game's story and mechanics continue to resonate with players.
Having the option to choose between the Xbox Series X and Series S could be a consideration for potential buyers and fans looking forward to revisiting the beloved Brothers title in its new glory. The distinction in performance and resolution as shown by Digital Foundry's analysis may sway decisions, highlighting the importance of hardware capabilities when it comes to experiencing remasters that utilize cutting-edge technology.
The gaming industry continues to advance, and with these developments, expectations rise for the kind of quality and fluidity that remakes, like Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, should deliver. While the Xbox Series X demonstrates that optimized performance for high-end remakes is achievable, the Xbox Series S's inability to keep up suggests there is still room for growth and optimization in this tier of console hardware. As technology progresses, we can likely anticipate further enhancements that will allow both consoles to showcase classic and remastered games in the best light possible.
You must be logged in to post a comment!
