In an effort to answer the intriguing question of which 16-bit era video game is the best, Nathan Lockard, a video game and data enthusiast, dedicated himself to a massive project. He played and rated every game from the 16-bit consoles: Super Nintendo Entertainment System (SNES), Sega Genesis (also known as Mega Drive), and the TurboGrafx-16 (also known as PC Engine). Remarkably, his quest covered a total of 1,515 games, making his dataset one of the most comprehensive of its kind in the gaming community.
Nathan Lockard isn’t new to the gaming industry. His background includes writing a book on video games and contributing to Nintendo Power magazine in the late 1990s. His experience and passion for gaming have fueled this extensive undertaking. By scoring games based on gameplay, level design, theme, art style, and sound design, Lockard has provided a detailed lens through which to view and compare these games.
Interestingly, Nathan’s reviews reveal fascinating statistical data about game distribution on these platforms. For example, fishing games comprise 1% of the entire Western Super NES library, sports games account for nearly 20% of the titles, and the TG-16 didn’t feature any fishing or soccer games.
When it comes to evaluating each game, Nathan devoted at least 30 minutes to playing each title. However, some genres like Adventure, Strategy, and RPG required more time due to their depth and complexity. This methodological approach was crucial to ensure a fair assessment while keeping the enormous project manageable.
His dedication bore fruit, offering not only scores but also brief overviews in a note form, which, despite sometimes containing typos and incomplete sentences, provides valuable insights bolstered by the weighted scores he assigned. The reviews tend to favor factual game feedback over elaborate prose, aligning with Nathan’s data-centric approach to this endeavor.
The insights into the top-scoring games are particularly interesting. Notably, Nathan’s analysis shows a strong preference for SNES titles, with games like Chrono Trigger, Contra III, Link to the Past, Mario World, Yoshi's Island, and Super Metroid all scoring perfection. These titles underscore the SNES’s legendary status among gaming enthusiasts. On the Sega Genesis, Gunstar Heroes emerged with a top score of 90. On the TurboGrafx-16, Soldier Blade was the highest-scoring game achieving a score of 91.
On the flip side, the quest also unearthed some of the worst games within the 16-bit era. Scoring a meager 2 out of 100 were titles like Dick Vitale's "Awesome, Baby!" College Hoops on Genesis and Super Hydlide, described by Nathan as a disastrously poor Zelda clone. These low scores highlight the variable quality across the extensive game libraries of these consoles.
Despite these low points, Nathan’s overall results showcase a spectrum of game quality ranging from groundbreaking classics to forgettable duds, providing a panoramic view of the 16-bit gaming era. For anyone curious about where a particular favorite game stands or interested in exploring lesser-known titles, Nathan’s complete work is available on the All 16-Bit blog, presenting a treasure trove of gaming history and analysis.
Through his monumental effort, Nathan Lockard has not only cataloged a vital slice of video game history but also provided valuable insights that can help both nostalgic players and curious new gamers navigate the rich landscape of 16-bit gaming. This ranking offers a unique tool for anyone interested in understanding the evolution of video games during this influential era. Whether you're revisiting old favorites or discovering classics for the first time, Nathan’s exhaustive work serves as a vital guide to the 16-bit gaming experience.
You must be logged in to post a comment!
