PC Gaming

Embark Pulls The Finals Esports Recap After AI Commentary Backlash

The Grand Major APAC Closed Qualifier highlight video replaced the broadcast's human casters with in-game hosts Scotty and June, prompting criticism from talent and a public apology.

Embark Pulls The Finals Esports Recap After AI Commentary Backlash

We may earn a commission when you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Embark Studios has removed a highlight recap for The Finals after the video sparked a major dispute over artificial intelligence, esports labor, and the role of broadcast talent in competitive gaming. The deleted video recapped action from The Grand Major APAC Closed Qualifiers, but did not use the commentary recorded by the real casters who covered the event live. Instead, it featured Scotty and June, the fictional announcers from the game, delivering newly produced commentary through the game's AI-driven system.

The reaction from casters and the wider esports community was swift. Several members of the broadcast team said the recap had effectively overwritten work they had spent months building across qualifier cycles, and that parts of the new script echoed language used during their original casts. While Embark has said the recap was made from selected broadcast clips and an original script rather than by feeding the event's video-on-demand footage directly into an AI system, critics have argued that the end result still minimized the people whose insight, preparation, and on-air work shaped the broadcast.

The incident has become more than a disagreement over one promotional video. For many freelancers and broadcast professionals, it has intensified a larger fear: that generative and automated tools could be used not merely to support a production, but to replace the human specialists who give esports events their personality, context, and credibility.

A recap meant to introduce esports to more players

The now-removed video was published through official The Finals social channels as a recap of the APAC Closed Qualifier ahead of The Grand Major, an official tournament for Embark's first-person shooter. In place of the original broadcast team, the video used Scotty and June, two familiar in-universe commentators designed to frame the game's competitive matches in the style of its fictional game show.

For useful background on this topic, read World of Warcraft's Death Music Has Players Asking an Unusual Azeroth Question.

Embark has previously expanded those characters' presence through a feature called Dynamic Commentary, announced in October. The system enables Scotty and June to reference player screen names and respond to particular match events. Their voices originate with human voice actors who were hired and paid for the work, while the resulting lines are delivered through text-to-speech technology and an AI model based on those voices.

That context made the qualifier recap especially contentious. AI-assisted commentary inside a regular match is one thing; many players see it as an extension of the game's presentation. But a tournament highlight package, particularly one constructed from a broadcast that employed human commentators, carries different expectations. Casters are not simply narrating kills and objectives. They research teams, identify stories, build tension, explain strategic decisions, and react in real time to unpredictable moments.

The concern was compounded when members of the APAC broadcast team felt the recap's new narration reflected phrases and framing that came from their own work. Commentator Proto, also known as Kai, said that he, TheeHyperactive, and Bluepanda_casts had contributed substantial time and emotion across four qualifier cycles, including both open and closed events, only to be replaced in the recap by the game's fictional hosts.

Casters say the situation reflects deeper frustration

Bluepanda described the episode in the context of a much longer career struggle. After nearly seven years of being told their work was valued, Bluepanda said they had repeatedly experienced being ignored or told that a production was moving in a different direction and no longer required their services. Following the controversy, Bluepanda said they were done with both the game and esports, citing the effort required of talent and the repeated difficulties faced by workers, especially in the Oceania region.

Other commentators from outside The Finals also criticized the decision. Marvel Rivals caster LemonKiwi objected to the idea that real casters' work could be displaced while recognizable elements of their phrasing appeared in the replacement commentary. Fighting game commentator Damascus similarly described the prospect of AI commentators built around human casting as alarming.

Those responses underline why the issue has resonated so widely. Competitive broadcasts are built by far more than the voices viewers hear most often. Producers, observers, camera operators, stage staff, editors, researchers, hosts, analysts, and many other freelancers all contribute to an event. If organizers conclude that AI-generated material is adequate for promotional recaps, workers fear that the same logic could eventually be applied across a much broader range of roles.

Proto warned that treating this approach as acceptable could create a precedent for tournament organizers seeking a cheaper alternative to experienced talent. He pointed out that automated observing tools already exist in some games, including systems that can shift perspectives between players without a person manually making every decision. That makes contractual protections important not only for casters, but for the people responsible for the technical and editorial side of esports broadcasts.

Embark removes the video and cancels similar recaps

Embark responded after the backlash by taking the APAC video down. The studio said its aim had been to use Scotty and June as familiar characters who could bring more casual interest to The Finals esports before The Grand Major. It said the production team selected broadcast clips, created a new script, and produced new commentary for the characters.

However, Embark acknowledged that excluding the casters and other talent who made the original broadcast was the wrong decision. The company confirmed that planned recap videos for the AMER and EMEA regions, which were intended to follow the same format, would no longer be released.

Oscar Lundberg, who works in Competitive Experience and Community for Embark and The Finals, also apologized publicly. Lundberg said the intent was to draw in casual viewers, but accepted that the original talent's work deserved to be included and highlighted. He confirmed the APAC recap would not return in its existing form and that the team was reconsidering the planned regional videos.

The apology and removal were important immediate steps, but they did not fully settle the concerns raised by talent. Critics noted that the format had apparently progressed from an initial idea into a finished, publicly released video without anyone recognizing the damage it could cause. For them, the issue is not solely whether the recap remains online; it is whether future contracts, creative decisions, and tournament plans will clearly respect the contributions and rights of human workers.

Questions about consent, credit, and contracts

Proto explained that organizers had described a process in which they identified key moments and storylines from the qualifier broadcast, then wrote a rough script for Scotty and June. The script was subsequently developed and turned into the final AI-driven lines. Proto said the broadcast VOD itself had not been directly entered into the AI, but argued that the new material nevertheless drew from moments and comments made by the original casters.

That distinction may matter technically, yet it does little to remove the creative and ethical questions. Human commentary is shaped by an individual's knowledge, timing, instinct, and voice. Even if a production team writes replacement lines from scratch, a recap that removes the original commentators after using their broadcast as its foundation can leave talent feeling erased from their own work.

Proto has called for industry-wide safeguards, including a union or coordinated action that would push organizers to offer contracts expressly preventing the use of a worker's voice in generative AI without clear permission. He also suggested that protections should cover production teams in addition to commentators. Such terms would not necessarily ban all AI tools from esports, but they could establish meaningful consent, compensation, and limits around how a person's work is repurposed.

Embark's other game, ARC Raiders, has also used AI-supported voice technology. In a November 2025 interview, design director Virgil Watkins said its voice actors had been hired under contracts that permitted AI use for systems such as contextual pings, allowing the game to reference many item names, locations, and compass directions without repeatedly bringing actors back to record each new variation. That model demonstrates one possible approach: establishing the intended use in advance through an agreement with the performer.

The qualifier recap controversy is different because it concerns people who had already been hired to cover a live esports event, then saw their work replaced in a promotional package. It is this gap between an in-game feature and the displacement of broadcast professionals that has made the reaction so intense.

The future of The Finals esports

Beyond the AI issue, Proto criticized the wider handling of The Finals competitive scene. He called for broader talent selection at major events, a more streamlined competitive structure next year, and stronger support for local communities that keep a grassroots scene active between marquee tournaments. His assessment was blunt: repeated organizational decisions have left people involved in the circuit frustrated and unhappy.

Embark has now committed to rethinking the three regional recap plans, but the episode will likely remain a significant warning for tournament organizers. AI can create scalable, reactive, in-universe presentation tools, and games may continue to experiment with them. Yet esports viewers and workers alike have made clear that a tool designed to add flavor to a game is not automatically an acceptable substitute for the people who make a live competitive broadcast meaningful.

For The Finals, the immediate video is gone. The longer-term challenge is rebuilding trust with the casters, production staff, players, and communities whose investment gives The Grand Major and future events their value in the first place.

Pass it on

Share this story

Portrait of Aaron Chisea

About the author

Aaron Chisea

Hey there, I'm Aaron Chisea! When I'm not pouring my heart into writing, you can catch me smashing baseballs at the batting cages or diving deep into the realms of World of Warcraft. From hitting home runs to questing in Azeroth, life's all about striking the perfect balance between the real and virtual worlds for me. Join me on this adventure, both on and off the page!

Community

Discussion

0

Start the conversation.
No comments have been posted yet.